“Cut my taxes,” seems to be the cry. And it’s been disastrous for the middle class.
How can that be? Well, here’s how it works. Consider two families: one earning $40,000 (average for Maine) and one earning $250,000 per year (rich, according to Obama). Suppose by some freak accident the government decides to give back 1 percent of their income each year (a non-progressive tax cut).
This is $400 a year for the $40,000 family and $2,500 a year for the $250,000 family. There’s a big difference here, but it’s only a small part of the story. What happens to that money down the line?
Maine families know exactly what happens to that $400 per year. Maybe the kids get new shoes for school, maybe some bills get up to date, maybe Mom goes out to eat on Mother’s Day, and so on.
Life is just a little bit better, but no real changes take place in family savings.
Things are different for the $250,000 family. It has a nice house, good entertainment, funds for the kids to go to college, full insurance (health and life), and a balanced retirement portfolio of investments. Thus $2,500 is pure gravy, every year. A wise family would invest it, at a high interest rate since the portfolio is already balanced.
Now, let’s look 10 years down the road. The $40,000 family has life just a little bit better, but it is not really ahead. But the $250,000 family sees something different. With only a little risk on the $2,500 per year, it could get 10 percent on that money, every year. It grows to almost $40,000.
That’s a big difference. Families who have access to financial markets and interest make out very well. This is one way tax cuts can shift the wealth.
It’s worse if we figure the real tax cuts, since they favor the wealthy.
It comes as no surprise that we’ve given our money to the wealthy. In 1980, the top 1 percent earned 10 percent of the income. By 2007, that had risen to almost 25 percent. The top 1 percent now own more than 90 percent of everything that can be owned in this country.
In addition, working people saw only small increases in their real income between 1980 and 2007, while the wealthy saw mind-boggling increases in their wealth. It’s all done with tax cuts.
What about our debt? Prior to 1980, the government oscillated between deficits and surpluses. Since 1980, however, it’s all huge and growing deficits, except the last years of the Clinton administration.
Adding up those deficits with interest since 1980 says the U.S. debt should have increased by about $7.7 trillion by 2007. The debt actually increased about $8.1 trillion.
Until the Great Recession, tax cuts account for most of the increase in the debt. After 2007, so many Americans lost jobs and houses and so many saw decreases in their income that tax revenues fell through the floor. That sharp decrease in tax revenues caused the debt to catapult. The debt increase during the Great Recession was about one-third the increase in the debt between 1980 and 2007.
All this is why the wealthy should pay their fair share.
The great Republican Teddy Roosevelt understood. He created the progressive income tax, whereby the wealthy pay more taxes than middle-income people.
And where are we now? The party of the rich says, “No tax increases,” not even to repair the debt it created with tax cuts.
Worse yet, it’s happening right here in Maine, where those in power say, “Let’s all give our money to the rich; they know what’s good for us.”
Tom R. Berger of Oakland is emeritus Carter Professor of Mathematics at Colby College.
Comments are no longer available on this story